An airport information screen displays an error message rather than travel information at San Francisco International Airport on Friday after a computer problem unraveled systems in the U.S. and dozens of other countries. (Talia Smith/NPR)
A technological meltdown left employees of airlines, banks, hospitals and emergency services around the world staring at the dreaded “blue screen of death” on Friday as their computers went inert in what is being described as a historic outage.
“This is basically what we were all worried about with Y2K, except it’s actually happened this time,” internet security analyst Troy Hunt said via X.
From continent to continent, Microsoft users reported being suddenly knocked offline, and the culprit was determined to be cybersecurity company CrowdStrike, which says one of its routine software updates malfunctioned.
“CrowdStrike is actively working with customers impacted by a defect found in a single content update for Windows hosts,” the company said in a statement.
Customers using Mac and Linux operating systems were not affected, CrowdStrike said.
When the faulty update crashed computer systems, scores of airport travelers were stranded, hospital appointments were delayed and live news broadcasts were cut short.
How big is the outage?
It is massive, far-reaching and sudden.
Some computer problems cascade, creating ripples of failures. But in this case, the flaw permeated Microsoft systems worldwide nearly immediately. The company says its Windows 365 Cloud PCs, apps and services were affected.
While server-related outages are common, the scale of the CrowdStrike disruption was astonishing to many tech observers.
“This IT outage is a stark reminder of how dependent we are on technology and many other things that happen behind the scenes that most of us are unaware of,” said Louisville-based tech executive Adam Robinson on X. “Modern society and the many comforts we enjoy is a fragile thing.”
What kinds of companies and services went offline?
Delta Airlines, United Airlines and American Airlines grounded all flights.
In some states, including Alaska and Ohio, 911 phone lines were down overnight Thursday, although Alaska State Troopers said on Facebook that service was restored by 4:30 a.m. Friday.
In Germany, some hospitals canceled non-emergency operations.
The London Stock Exchange’s news service stopped working.
Broadcasters around the world were also hit. In France and Australia, live television broadcasts were knocked offline.
Sky News, a major U.K. news channel, was off air for a time on Friday morning. It later returned, but without “full capabilities,” its chairman, David Rhodes, said on X Friday afternoon. A post on Australia’s ABC News website said the broadcaster was experiencing a “major network outage.”
How do people fix their computers?
CrowdStrike says the problem was not a cyberattack, but rather a software glitch. The company said the issue has been identified and that a fix was sent to customers.
It also published a workaround that involves booting a Windows machine in a recovery environment, deleting a single file in the CrowdStrike directory, and restarting.
What is CrowdStrike?
It’s a U.S. cybersecurity firm based in Austin, Texas. The company went public in 2019 and is currently in the S&P 500 index. As of early July, CrowdStrike’s stock had been riding months of gains. But share prices fell sharply in early trading Friday.
“This is clearly a major black eye for CrowdStrike,” said WedBush analyst Dan Ives.
CrowdStrike made headlines in 2016, when the company was hired by the Democratic National Committee to investigate a breach of its data systems. CrowdStrike determined that the hack was a case of foreign interference — the work of Russian-backed hacking groups.
The company’s marquee product is its “Falcon” cybersecurity software — and it traced the current problem to a change in a sensor in that system. That also helps explain how and why the resulting failures spread so quickly: Rather than being stored locally, the Falcon security platform “is 100% cloud-based.”
PepsiCo said sales of its Frito-Lay snacks slumped in the most recent quarter as shoppers became more sensitive to rising prices. (Justin Sullivan | Getty Images North America)
Grocery prices are no longer climbing as much as they did in the last two years — but many Americans are still frustrated by what it costs to put food on the table.
Some people have apparently hit their limit. One of the biggest snack makers said this week that its sales fell this spring as grocery shoppers became more sensitive to rising prices.
Here are three things to know about food prices these days — and why it still feels more expensive at the checkout lane of your favorite grocery store.
What is going on with food prices?
It may not feel like it, but grocery prices have actually leveled off for the most part.
The latest consumer inflation report, out this week, showed grocery prices rose just a little over 1% in the last 12 months. That’s a big improvement from the previous year, when prices jumped nearly 5%, and the year before that, when they soared by double digits.
However, leveling off is not the same as prices coming down, and the U.S. is still feeling the cumulative effect of those earlier increases.
And that leads to frustration for shoppers like Cindy Seinar, a retired autoworker in Lynchburg, Virginia.
“You go in for one thing, and you come out and it’s $45,” she says, describing her experiences at the grocery store.
And for Seinar, just like for many other Americans, the frustration is compounded by “shrinkflation.” That’s when companies reduce package sizes, meaning you get less than you used to for the same or sometimes even higher prices.
“Sugar is only 4 pounds,” Seinar says. “You’re not even getting a 5-pound bag anymore.”
Grocery prices are particularly noticeable because they are such a significant chunk of the typical family’s budget, accounting for about 8% on average, according to government data. For lower-income families, it’s often more than that.
How are people adjusting to higher prices?
For a while, many people just gritted their teeth and paid up — but Americans are starting to push back.
PepsiCo, which reported earnings this week, said sales of its Frito-Lay snacks actually fell during the most recent quarter. Some of that is because shoppers are balking at the higher prices by cutting back on chips altogether or by switching to cheaper store brands.
Amanda Whitworth stocks grocery shelves at a Target store in Florida. She often finds herself steering customers to the in-house bargains at the discount retailer.
“You may not ever have considered the Market Pantry bread, but it’s $1.39 for a big loaf of it,” Whitworth says, referring to Target’s private label. “While that may not be someone’s first choice, it’s a quarter of the price of some loaves.”
Grocery prices rose just a little over 1% in the last 12 months, according to the latest consumer inflation report, out this week. (Frederic J. Brown | AFP via Getty Images)
Whitworth also does the food shopping for her family and says she has made similar substitutions of her own.
“Before, we would have bought a big bag of frozen chicken nuggets for our son. And the particular bag went up three extra dollars,” Whitworth says. “So we started making homemade chicken nuggets, which we’ll probably never switch back because they’re so good.”
That sends a message to the big food producers. When PepsiCo and others start losing market share, they grow more cautious about pushing up prices. In some cases, they start to offer discounts — and that’s one reason grocery prices aren’t climbing as fast as they had been.
So are grocery prices finally going to come down?
To some degree.
The prices of some individual grocery items have come down. Fruit and vegetable prices have dropped over the last year, for example. So have milk and cheese prices.
However, the overall cost of groceries is unlikely to fall substantially.
But there is a silver lining. As grocery inflation slows, wages are catching up.
Over the last year, average wages have risen 3.9%, or about three and a half times as fast as grocery prices.
The typical worker now has to work about the same number of hours to buy a week’s worth of groceries as in 2019, before the COVID-19 pandemic.
That’s good news — even if for many Americans it doesn’t feel that way.
Transcript:
SCOTT SIMON, HOST:
How much would you pay for a bag of potato chips? Well, some people are apparently hitting their limit. One of the biggest snackmakers say that its sales fell this spring because of rising prices. Grocery prices are not climbing nearly as fast as they had been, but many Americans are still frustrated by what it costs to put food on the table. NPR’s Scott Horsley joins us. Scott, thanks for being with us.
SCOTT HORSLEY, BYLINE: Good morning. Good to be with you.
SIMON: Of course, a lot of people will be in supermarkets this weekend. What kind of prices might they see?
HORSLEY: Well, the good news is supermarket prices have largely leveled off. We got an inflation report this past week showing grocery prices rose just a little over 1% in the last 12 months. That is a big improvement from the previous year, when prices jumped almost 5%, and the year before that, when they soared by double digits. But leveling off is not the same as coming down, and we are still dealing with the cumulative effect of all those earlier price increases. When we asked NPR listeners, where do you feel the sting of inflation most? – a lot of people said the supermarket.
CINDY SIENAR: I think that groceries stand out the most just because we’re always at the grocery store, and you have to eat.
HORSLEY: Cindy Sienar is a retired autoworker who lives in Virginia. Like a lot of people, she’s bothered by what economists call shrinkflation and the feeling she’s paying more and getting less.
SIENAR: You go in for one thing, and you come out, and it’s $45. And sugar is only four pounds. You’re not even getting a five-pound bag anymore.
HORSLEY: And people notice because, you know, they buy groceries week after week. It’s a significant chunk of the typical family’s budget, about 8% on average. For lower-income families, it’s often more than that.
SIMON: And how are people reacting to these higher prices?
HORSLEY: You know, for a while, they just grit their teeth and paid up, but we are starting to see more pushback now. Pepsi, which reported its earnings this past week, said, sales of FritoLay snacks were actually down during the most recent quarter, which suggests we have reached the crunch point on tortilla chips. You know, maybe shoppers are cutting back altogether or they’re switching to cheaper store brands.
Amanda Whitworth stocks grocery shelves at a Target store in Florida. She often steers customers to the discount retailer’s in-house bargains.
AMANDA WHITWORTH: I like being able to point people in certain directions and be like, well, you may not have ever considered the market pantry bread, but it’s $1.39 for a big loaf of it. And you know, while that might not be someone’s first choice, you know, it’s a quarter of the price of some loafs.
HORSLEY: Whitworth also does the food shopping for her family and says she’s made some substitutions of her own.
WHITWORTH: Before, we would have bought a big bag of frozen chicken nuggets for our son, and the particular bag went up three extra dollars, and at that point, I was like, oh, goodness. So we started making homemade chicken nuggets, which – we’ll probably never switch back ’cause they’re so good.
HORSLEY: That sends a message to the big food producers. You know, when Pepsi and others start losing market share, they get more cautious about raising prices, and, in some cases, they start to offer discounts.
SIMON: Scott, are food prices, grocery prices, likely to come down any time soon?
HORSLEY: You know, the price of some individual items will certainly come down. We’ve seen that over the last year with fruits and vegetables and milk and cheese. But in terms of what you pay at checkout for the whole grocery cart, that’s not likely to drop very much.
The good news is as grocery prices level off, wages are catching up. Over the last year, average wages have risen about 3 1/2 times as fast as grocery prices. So one way to think about this is, how long do I have to work to buy a week’s worth of groceries? For the typical worker, it now takes about the same number of hours as it did back in 2019, even if it doesn’t yet feel that way.
Safeway in Juneau on Wednesday, July 10, 2024. (Clarise Larson/KTOO)
Kroger and Albertsons plan to sell 18 grocery stores in Alaska, including Juneau’s Safeway in the Mendenhall Valley, as part of the plan to merge the two grocery giants.
The CEOs of Kroger and Albertsons shared a joint video statement following the announcement. Albertsons CEO Vivek Sankaran said the sales will help keep prices low and give more options to shoppers.
“This merger is the right thing for our customers and our associates,” he said. “For our customers, we strengthen the American retail landscape and thoughtfully selected stores to ensure customers continue to have a choice of where to shop.”
A list released on Tuesday includes Carrs, Eagle and Safeway stores across Alaska — and more than 550 other stores across the U.S.
The merger plan still needs to be approved by regulators. But, if that happens, the 579 stores on the list will be transferred to C&S Wholesale Grocers, LLC. C&S operates grocery stores across the country, including Piggly Wiggly, and is the nation’s largest wholesale grocery supplier.
Kroger CEO Rodney McMullen said the list is a significant step toward completing the merger.
“Divested stores are not closed stores,” he said. “C&S is committed to operating these stores as they are today.”
Despite the excitement expressed by the CEOs, the plan has seen a lot of pushback since it was announced in the fall of 2022.
Local municipalities, state lawmakers and Alaska’s U.S. delegation have called to block the merger, arguing it could cause more food insecurity in rural places in Alaska, drive up prices and limit options.
And the Federal Trade Commission and attorneys general in states like Washington, Illinois and California have filed suits to stop the merger.
In a statement, Rep. Mary Peltola said she would “continue to support the FTC’s efforts to block this merger.”
If the merger is approved, the divestiture of the stores will be roughly $3 billion. The companies say there are no plans to lay off employees at the stores.
Xin Li, a research and development associate, works at Ascend Elements in Westborough, Mass., on June 13. The company is one of several that are scrambling to build recycling plants that can recover minerals from electric vehicle batteries without using dirty techniques like burning them — or wasting energy by shipping them overseas. (Amanda Andrade-Rhoades for NPR)
WESTBOROUGH, Mass. — Plastic bags of dark powder sit on a metal shelf. The powder contains minerals that came from lithium-ion batteries and are destined to be made into batteries again. That, in itself, is not revolutionary.
But where this shelf is located — in an unassuming industrial park an hour west of Boston — symbolizes how the battery-recycling industry is on the cusp of change.
Today, key steps in the battery-recycling process mostly happen overseas, particularly in Asia. Companies there have spent years building up a battery supply chain in which recycling and building batteries are closely connected.
But more and more batteries spend their lives powering electric vehicles in the United States. Shipping minerals halfway around the world costs money, creates carbon emissions, adds supply chain risks and, from the U.S. perspective, pushes some jobs and profits overseas.
That’s why the U.S. government is pouring money into an effort to bring the whole battery-recycling ecosystem to the United States. Meanwhile, automakers and battery companies, as they build new battery and EV plants across North America, want recycling close by; they’ll have a lot of batteries to scrap in the years ahead as electric vehicle sales rise.
These minerals in their 25-pound plastic bags, recycled by a company called Ascend Elements, epitomize the new geography of battery recycling. They were ground up in Georgia, processed in Massachusetts and headed to Michigan for manufacturing — every step happening in the United States.
Keeping battery minerals closer to home
Lithium-ion batteries are hazardous waste if they’re discarded, but they’re a valuable resource if they’re recycled.
Because they’re hazardous, some states legally require battery recycling. And because they’re valuable, EV batteries are often recycled even where it’s not mandated: Vehicle dismantlers can sell the batteries for money.
But how does it work? Step 1 is safely collecting batteries, discharging them and then disassembling and shredding them. The result is a black powder that’s called “black mass” in the battery-recycling industry. This happens at locations scattered across the U.S., including at an Ascend Elements facility in Georgia.
Chemical operator Pedro Servones works on a tank at Ascend Elements on June 13. (Amanda Andrade-Rhoades for NPR)Brian Gaulin picks up a scoop of “black mass,” the material left after batteries are shredded and sifted, at Ascend Elements on June 13. (Amanda Andrade-Rhoades for NPR)
Then that powder of jumbled-up minerals is frequently shipped overseas to get turned back into something useful. In Westborough, Mass., Ascend Elements is doing those steps closer to home. The powder gets combined with sulfuric acid, where some minerals dissolve and others don’t, making it easier to sort them apart.
Ascend takes out (and in some cases, sells off separately) everything except the nickel, cobalt and other costly minerals that go into a battery’s cathode. The levels of each mineral get fine-tuned, and the mixture is dried back into a powder again.
Last month, the company began shipping the powder coming off the line — precursor cathode active material (pCAM), to use its technical term — to a buyer that will put the material into batteries for heavy-duty vehicles. Ascend believes this is likely the first time that pCAM made wholly in the U.S. from recycled materials is being used in commercial manufacturing.
Newer, cleaner processes for recycling batteries
In some cases, recycling processes, not just locations, are also changing. An older method relied on burning battery materials, which wasted many of the minerals and created pollution.
A newer method involves dissolving the minerals in acid instead, recovering more minerals with less waste (or potentially no waste, if companies reuse water and find uses for all their chemical byproducts). “Recyclers all across the world are adopting this technology,” says battery expert Beatrice Browning.
Meanwhile, Ascend is skipping several steps by not isolating all the minerals separately, like most acid-based processes do. “That’s extracting 98% of the material because you’re worried about the 2% of impurities,” co-founder and Chief Technology Officer Eric Gratz explains. “So we flip the problem around, and we’re extracting the 2% of impurities and keeping the nickel, manganese and cobalt together.”
Eric Gratz, co-founder of Ascend Elements, poses for a portrait at the company’s battery-recycling facility in Westborough, Mass., on June 13. (Amanda Andrade-Rhoades for NPR)
Imagine you have a large Lego creation and you want to make a different Lego creation. Melting the whole thing down would be a brute-force waste of energy. Taking it apart and sorting all the bricks is more finicky but much more effective — like extracting out each mineral one by one. What Ascend is doing is more like breaking it down but not sorting all the bricks, just keeping them together in a big pile.
Meanwhile, some companies are working on a form of recycling called “direct recycling” that would take the battery apart without shredding it at all. It’s like keeping big chunks of Lego bricks together and reusing them as a single unit. And still other companies are exploring new ways to use electricity or other technologies to refine how metals are, well, refined.
A dual purpose: cutting emissions, boosting profits
Ascend’s production line is built right behind the company’s research and development lab, where Matthew Valdiviezo is watching a vivid teal liquid spin in a beaker as he explains that chemistry is all about rules. And his work is all about manipulating those rules — “to make us money in the long run,” he says, “and help the planet, of course.”
For many environmentally conscious drivers, battery disposal is a major concern. And it’s true that if batteries wind up in landfills, they would be a serious problem. But environmental advocates see a huge opportunity in recycling.
“Battery recycling can play, in the long run, a really big role in making electric vehicles more sustainable,” says Dale Hall of the International Council on Clean Transportation. “Decades from now, we’ll need very little new virgin raw materials to build new EVs. And that’s very different from what you have now with combustion engine vehicles, where you’re going to always have to be producing new virgin oil and feeding tons and tons of that into the vehicles over their lifetime.”
Meanwhile, Valdiviezo’s other motivation — the bottom line? That’s real too, and lots of other companies are chasing it.
Redwood Materials, started by a Tesla co-founder, is building multibillion-dollar plants in Nevada and South Carolina. “There is an incredible opportunity to create this closed-loop supply chain here domestically for the first time,” the company’s vice president of government relations and communications, Alexis Georgeson, told NPR in an interview earlier this year.
And, she noted, battery recycling is profitable today.
Cirba Solutions, another big player, is working on plants in Ohio and South Carolina. “We’re building as fast as we humanly possibly can build,” says CEO David Klanecky. “And I think we’re going way too slow, to be honest with you.”
A scientist measures precursor cathode active material (pCAM) at Ascend Elements on June 13. (Amanda Andrade-Rhoades for NPR)Battery materials engineer Alfred Nkhama works at Ascend Elements on June 13. (Amanda Andrade-Rhoades for NPR)
“It’s not fast enough”
The pressure for speed might seem counterintuitive. EV batteries can last more than a dozen years (maybe much longer — the first mass-market EVs aren’t old enough to have much data beyond that). Some outlive their vehicles and could have a second life, like storing backup power for a building. And there aren’t that many EVs on the roads — yet.
But EVs from the first generation are starting to reach the end of their lives. Recalled batteries or those damaged in vehicular accidents also need to be recycled, as does scrap material coming from the production lines of plants manufacturing new batteries. Meanwhile, the nascent battery-manufacturing industry in the U.S. is hungry for materials, especially ones that meet made-in-America requirements for federal incentives.
That’s pushing companies to move fast. “Two years ago, there was nothing in here,” says Ascend senior process engineer Zain Nasir at the plant in Westborough. “The amount of hours everybody’s put in trying to get this place to where it is is just incredible.”
In the lab where she was testing products to confirm their quality, Rebecca Neslusan laughed when I asked her about the timeline. “The pressure is on,” she said. “As fast as we can do it, it’s not fast enough.”
In fact, the milestone that Ascend hit in June — that first commercial shipment out of this manufacturing line — is itself proof of the sense of urgency. For a chemical plant, the production line here in Massachusetts is tiny. It was originally meant to be a pilot, a proof of concept. But the demand is too high.
“We’re shipping here because the customer wants and needs the material as soon as possible, you know, basically faster than we can build our facilities,” says Gratz, the company’s co-founder and CTO.
His billion-dollar plant in Kentucky is due to open early next year.
Transcript:
JUANA SUMMERS, HOST:
There’s a race underway in the world of electric vehicles, but it is not about sprint times. This race is about who’s going to recycle EV batteries here in the U.S. Right now, much of it happens in Asia, and shipping valuable minerals halfway around the world has costs in terms of money, carbon emissions, U.S. jobs. NPR’s Camila Domonoske takes us to one of the companies trying to remake the geography of battery recycling.
CAMILA DOMONOSKE, BYLINE: Past a lab with liquids spinning and dripping in giant beakers – quick pause for safety gear.
ERIC GRATZ: So let’s grab some goggles.
(SOUNDBITE OF PLASTIC RUSTLING)
DOMONOSKE: Through a nondescript door…
(SOUNDBITE OF DOOR SQUEAKING)
DOMONOSKE: …There’s a miniature chemical plant tacked onto the back of Ascend Elements’ R&D facility in Massachusetts. Now, miniature is relative.
GRATZ: I mean, we have tanks that are up to 18 feet tall.
DOMONOSKE: Eric Gratz is Ascend’s co-founder and chief technical officer.
GRATZ: And then this one here, which is taller than me, is one of our smallest tanks.
DOMONOSKE: But this is a fraction of the size of the factory Ascend is building in Kentucky. This month, this little plant sent its first commercial shipment of battery materials fully recycled in the U.S. The company thinks that’s a first for their kind of product. They’ll go back into batteries for things like electric construction vehicles. If you don’t recycle batteries, they’re hazardous waste, but if you do, they’re a valuable resource. The more you recycle, the less you need to mine. Step one is collecting and pulverizing batteries. Employee Brian Garland scoops some black powder for me.
BRIAN GARLAND: Hang on, let me just give you a little so you can see it. And that’s what we get from shredding the batteries.
DOMONOSKE: Literally shredding them – this step has been happening in the U.S. for a while. But today, that powder of jumbled up minerals mostly gets shipped to Asia, where companies had a big head start on building battery supply chains for the next steps. These molecules are going on a short journey here in the states. Gratz leads the tour.
GRATZ: Then you get pumped down to that leaching tank there where you’ll be dissolved in sulfuric acid.
DOMONOSKE: Some of the minerals, like nickel and cobalt, dissolve. The graphite in the mix doesn’t. That helps sort them apart.
GRATZ: Then you’re going to go over to our impurity removal station.
DOMONOSKE: The exact combination of minerals gets fine-tuned, and finally, it’s dried back into a powder, currently sitting on a shelf in 25-pound bags.
GRATZ: So it comes in as a powder, and it’s leaving as a powder. It’s just coming in, you know, very impure and – but leaving very pure.
DOMONOSKE: Doing this whole process in the states is a priority for the Biden administration. The idea is to promote jobs and secure supply chains as well as fight climate change. The federal government is pouring money into this industry. But it’s not just where this is happening that’s different. Companies are trying to make the process more efficient and cleaner. At Ascend’s R&D lab right next to that production line, Matthew Valdiviezo, standing before a beaker of swirling bright teal liquid, says chemistry is all about rules.
MATTHEW VALDIVIEZO: So we’re trying to manipulate the rules here to make us money in the long run, you know, and help the planet, of course.
DOMONOSKE: Environmental groups do think battery recycling can help the planet if it’s done right. To explain how these processes are improving – imagine you have a big LEGO creation, and you want to make a different LEGO creation. Melting it down to make new Lego bricks would obviously be a huge waste of energy. Taking it apart and sorting all the bricks – that’s more finicky, but cleaner. Now, Ascend figured out you don’t even have to sort all the bricks.
GRATZ: We’re just removing the 2% that we don’t want and keeping the 98% that we want together.
DOMONOSKE: Lots of companies with different approaches are scaling up battery recycling in the states and trying to do it quickly. At Ascend, Rebecca Neslusan is testing samples and feeling a sense of urgency.
REBECCA NESLUSAN: The pressure is on to, you know, make this product. And as fast as we can do it, it’s not fast enough even then.
DOMONOSKE: In fact, the very existence of this mini chemical plant is a testament to this pressure. This is a research lab. There was never meant to be a commercial line here, but the EV industry is demanding recycled minerals now. And Ascend’s billion-dollar plant in Kentucky – it’s due to open next year.
Camila Domonoske, NPR News, Westboro, Mass.
(SOUNDBITE OF DANILO PLESSOW AND THE MOTOR CITY DRUM ENSEMBLE’S “THE STRANGER”)
The site of the former Wrangell Medical Center. (Sage Smiley/KSTK)
Wrangell’s former hospital building had a buyer, but he has quashed the deal — citing a headline in the local newspaper.
The project would have renovated the old Wrangell Medical Center into much-needed housing. But Georgia resident Wayne Johnson ended his plans because he didn’t like a headline in the Wrangell Sentinel that read: “Hospital property developer now wants borough lots for free.”
Johnson intended to purchase the building for $200,000, which is significantly less than the appraised value of $800,000.
He also planned to buy the six adjacent lots and he said he was going to develop between 36 and 40 housing units on the property.
“Unfortunately, the local newspaper decided to characterize it as the lots being conveyed under, I think the headline was, ‘Developer now wants borough lots for free,’” Johnson said. “I never wanted anything for free.”
The City and Borough of Wrangell offered Johnson the six lots for free if he demolished the asbestos-filled medical center by June 30, 2026. But Johnson said there were still inherent costs — he estimated the demolition expenses at roughly $1 million. Johnson said the Sentinel’s headline was inaccurate, which caused him to pull out of his investment.
“I’m just in a situation where, you know, just my reputation and my intents are very positive towards the city of Wrangell,” he said. “I felt like the headline, unfortunately, and even portions of the story, misrepresented what the city and I had agreed to.”
He said withdrawing from developing the lots removes any doubt others might have in him.
The Wrangell Sentinel’s publisher, Larry Persily, disagrees that the headline was wrong.
“I felt the story was accurate. The headline was accurate,” he said. “It’s unfortunate that Mr. Johnson has decided to cancel his investment and development plans in Wrangell.”
Originally, Johnson was supposed to close on the purchase by May 31. But then he asked the borough for the adjacent land at a reduced cost.
The borough agreed to change the contract to include a requirement for demolishing the building, which would save the borough from liability. And, in return, Johnson would get the six lots for free.
Persily questions whether it really was the headline that changed Johnson’s course.
“So it all changed because of a headline, which I find somewhat a convenient excuse for someone who maybe didn’t want to follow through after all,” he said.
Persily has been in Alaska journalism and politics for decades. He said he does not feel a need to defend the headline.
“I’ve been at this for 50 years,” he said. “I’ve been called worse things by better people. No, I don’t (think I need to defend myself). I feel I should explain myself when people ask.”
Earlier this year, Persily said he had a few interactions with Johnson when reporting on the development project. He said their interactions were cordial until June 28, two days after the headline came out.
He said that Johnson accused him of purposefully writing the headline for clickbait or sensationalizing it for attention.
“Look, clickbait,” Persily said. “I think (what) people in Wrangell use bait for is fishing, not social media.”
Borough Manager Mason Villarma said he doesn’t have much to say on the withdrawal, except that he appreciates the time everyone spent on planning.
“A lot of staff worked hard on seeing through as far as we could go,” he said. “Moving on and what I hear is we have two interested parties already.”
The borough spends approximately $100,000 a year to maintain the old hospital building. It was estimated that demolishing the building would cost $2 million.
As for Johnson’s future in Wrangell, the Georgia resident said he intends to continue to visit often. He has a two-year lease on the island, has two boats docked in town and is looking for land to build a house on. He also brought a food truck to Wrangell to sell boiled crab.
And he’s running as a Republican for U.S. Congress in Georgia this year.
“I will be leaving in a couple of weeks to head back to Georgia to fully engage in my campaign for the United States Congress,” Johnson said. “It’s going to be a very intense few months.”
Elvia Elena Nunez and her grandson Esteban spent several months this spring in the Kith and Kin program. (Andrea Hsu | NPR)
A half dozen women — in their 30s, 40s and 50s — gather in a classroom in Phoenix for a few hours on a weekday morning.
They are all caregivers of young children.
There’s Yosbri Rojas. When her own 8-year-old is at school, she takes care of two younger children, whose father works with Rojas’ husband installing fiber optic lines.
“I like that the children feel happy with me,” Rojas says in Spanish.
Graciela Cruz is also here. She works early mornings in a warehouse, from 4 to 9 a.m. During the day, she parents her own 2-year-old daughter and also watches her neighbors’ 1-year-old while the child’s parents are at work cleaning houses and offices.
Cruz and Rojas are participants in an Arizona state-funded initiative called Kith and Kin. The 12-week program aims to give family, friend and neighbor caregivers the kind of training and support that licensed caregivers are required to have.
Licensed or not, caregivers make work possible
While most federal and state funding for child care in the U.S. goes to licensed settings, Arizona is one of a number of states that have long recognized the importance of informal caregiving arrangements that are allowing millions of parents go to work.
Such arrangements, which can be paid or unpaid, are especially common in immigrant communities and communities of color, where many parents hold jobs with nontraditional hours and prefer caregivers who share their language and culture.
A half dozen women gather to discuss caregiving issues with their instructor Idely Valenzuela as part of the Kith and Kin program. (Andrea Hsu | NPR)
A study in the south Phoenix area found that 60% of children from birth to 5 years old were being cared for outside of licensed child care settings.
That study led the nonprofit organization Candelen to launch Kith and Kin in 1999.
“There was the high need to provide both training and support” in communities where families with young children live, says program director Angela Tapia.
Now, 25 years later, programs like Kith and Kin are getting renewed attention in the wake of the pandemic, which put a spotlight on the fragile state of the child care industry.
There’s increased urgency from federal and state policymakers and businesses to ensure communities have access to affordable, high-quality child care, paving the way for parents — especially women — to work, an essential element of a robust and well-functioning economy.
A crash course in caregiving fundamentals
The aunts and grandmothers and neighbors who attend the Kith and Kin classes often don’t think of themselves as caregivers, says Tapia, much less as contributing to the economy.
“It’s more something they do out of love and to help their family and friends,” she says.
But caregiving requires more than love, and that’s where the program come in.
Over 12 weeks, the caregivers, who are predominantly women (though they do see the occasional grandfather or uncle) undergo training in basic health and safety, including CPR, as well as more advanced topics such as child development, positive discipline and injury prevention.
The women share personal challenges, ask for advice and offer comfort and support.
Funding comes from Arizona’s tobacco tax
The sessions are paid for in part by Arizona’s tobacco tax. Candelen estimates it trains about 1,000 caregivers a year.
Melinda Gulick, CEO of Arizona’s early childhood agency First Things First, says the funding is recognition that all children, regardless of where they spend their first years, deserve a high quality early childhood experience.
“Being ready on the first day of Kindergarten is the biggest indicator of academic success and success in life as well,” she says.
Gulick points out, in some rural parts of Arizona, there is no licensed child care, and even where there are options, Arizonans are known for wanting choice.
“This is a liberty and freedom state,” she says. “For many parents, the best place for [children] to be is with their auntie or their grandmother or in a co-op in their neighborhood.”
Cynthia Diarte with her 2-year-old son Esteban in front of their home in Phoenix. (Andrea Hsu | NPR)
Keeping caregiving in the family
That’s certainly how Cynthia Diarte felt when she had her son Esteban. He’s now two and a big fan of Bluey, the beloved children’s television character.
Diarte, a teacher, grew up on the Texas-Mexico border, cared for by her grandmother while her mother went to work at an airport restaurant.
Diarte says it was never a question who would watch her children when she became a mother herself. Her mother, Elvia Elena Nunez, insisted she be the one, carrying on their family tradition.
“As his grandmother, my love is different from any other caregiver,” Nunez says in Spanish.
As a Kith and Kin participant, Nunez has appreciated learning new ways to keep Esteban entertained without screens. She also cherishes the community she’s built with the other caregivers and the enrichment Esteban has gotten through the program.
While class is in session, Esteban is with other toddlers, singing songs and playing games in the child care room down the hall.
“He’s bringing more vocabulary. He’s starting to speak up a little bit more,” says Diarte. “He really needed that social aspect, the relationship with other kids.”
And she expects those relationships to endure. A side benefit of the Kith and Kin classes is how close the caregivers become.
“They end up becoming like the madrinas, like the godmothers, the godparents, to each other’s children,” says program director Tapia. “They stay connected throughout the years.”
Transcript:
JUANA SUMMERS, HOST:
Caregivers are often spoken of as the workforce behind the workforce. They include millions of moms, grandmas, aunts, friends and neighbors who watch other people’s kids while parents go to work. In Arizona, a nonprofit has long worked to get these informal caregivers everything they need to do that job well. NPR’s Andrea Hsu reports from Phoenix.
(CROSSTALK)
ANDREA HSU, BYLINE: A half-dozen women, from their 30s to their 50s, gather for a few hours on a weekday morning. They are all caregivers at least part of the time. Take Yosbri Rojas, who has a son in elementary school. During the mornings…
YOSBRI ROJAS: (Speaking Spanish).
HSU: She offered to take care of two preschoolers while their dad, who works with Rojas’ husband, is off installing fiber-optic lines. Graciela Cruz is also here. She works early mornings in a warehouse from 4 to 9 a.m. So during the day, she also watches two children, one of them her own.
GRACIELA CRUZ: I have a 2-year-old daughter, and I take care of a 1-year-old.
HSU: The child of her neighbors, who clean houses and offices for a living. Cruz and Rojas are part of a 12-week program called Kith and Kin. It’s one of many initiatives Arizona is turning to to address a child care shortage in the state, but it was actually created 25 years ago to introduce standards to informal caregiving. Program director Angela Tapia says the program grew out of a study that looked at where children, birth to 5, were being cared for in the South Phoenix area.
ANGELA TAPIA: Sixty percent of children are actually in family, friend and neighbor care. And so there was a high need to provide both training and support in the communities that these families live.
HSU: Communities like this predominantly Spanish-speaking one, where parents often hold jobs with nontraditional hours and prefer caregivers who share their culture and language. The caregivers are playing a crucial role in the economy, enabling so many parents to go to work. Still, Tapia says, they often don’t see themselves that way.
TAPIA: It’s more something they do out of love and to help their family and friends.
HSU: Of course, caregiving is about much more than love. Over the 12 weeks, the women learn about everything from basic health and safety to more advanced topics, including one of Graciela Cruz’s favorites – child development.
CRUZ: Brain development – I never, like, thought it was so much for a baby. I’m glad I took this class.
HSU: Now most government funding for childcare goes to licensed providers, but Arizona has long supported these unlicensed caregivers, too. Kith and Kin is paid for in part by the state’s tobacco tax. Melinda Gulick is with the state agency, First Things First, that administers those funds.
MELINDA GULICK: It’s that recognition of the family, friend and neighbor – the home care centers that we really want to support so that all the children are getting a quality early learning experience, No. 1. And No. 2, parents can go to work.
HSU: Which has become a huge priority since the pandemic. Gulick says, in some rural parts of the state, there is no licensed child care. And even where there are options, Arizonans are known for wanting choice.
GULICK: This is the Wild West, right? This is a liberty and freedom state. And so for many parents, the best place for them to be is with their auntie or their grandmother or in a co-op in their neighborhood.
HSU: That’s certainly how Elvia Nunez feels about her grandson, Esteban.
ELVIA NUNEZ: (Speaking Spanish).
HSU: She says when her daughter, who’s a teacher, gave birth, she insisted that she be the one to watch the baby.
NUNEZ: (Speaking Spanish).
HSU: “As his grandmother,” she says, “my love is different from any other caregiver.”
Nunez says she’s gotten a lot out of the Kith and Kin class, including learning all kinds of ways to keep the 2-year-old entertained without screens.
NUNEZ: (Speaking Spanish).
HSU: She says technology isn’t good for him at this age. Meanwhile, while she’s in class, Esteban gets to be with other kids in the child care room down the hall.
UNIDENTIFIED GROUP: (Singing) Hello, hello.
UNIDENTIFIED PERSON #1: (Speaking Spanish).
UNIDENTIFIED GROUP: (Singing) Can you stomp your feet?
HSU: It’s helped him hit milestones around language and socialization.
ESTEBAN: (Vocalizing).
UNIDENTIFIED PERSON #2: (Inaudible).
ESTEBAN: (Vocalizing).
UNIDENTIFIED PERSON #2: Yeah.
HSU: At the end of the 12 weeks, the women mark milestones of their own with a graduation ceremony.
(CHEERING)
UNIDENTIFIED PERSON #3: Bravo. (Speaking Spanish). Bravo.
HSU: And then they go back to work, nurturing the next generation and doing their part for the economy.
Andrea Hsu, NPR News, Phoenix.
(SOUNDBITE OF STORMZY SONG, “HIDE AND SEEK”)
Close
Update notification options
Subscribe to notifications
Subscribe
Get notifications about news related to the topics you care about. You can unsubscribe anytime.